Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...

Rob P

Members
  • Content Count

    140
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

39 Lord Celestant

About Rob P

  • Rank
    Decimator

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. You gent; thank you. Didn't even know that existed.
  2. The two wood-elf heroes that have been squatted were easily the best sculpts of their day. it doesn't look good for them particularly in the context of Sylvaneth being a thing and the force opposing Beasts of Chaos in the next Shadespire box.
  3. Hi Sorry if the post i'm looking for is in a very obvious place (I did look and try and search before posting). Is there still a stickied post setting out the square to round base conversions? I've got a bunch of square based stuff under the bed that I really need to get AOS ready. Thanks Rob
  4. This might be a silly question but what am i missing here: Q: Does the note in the Pitched Battle profile for Tzaangors in the Beasts of Chaos battletome mean that they can only ever be Battleline if they are included in a Beasts of Chaos army with a Tzaangor Shaman as their general? A: No. Tzaangors are only not Battleline units when they are taken as part of a Beasts of Chaos army that does not have a Tzaangor Shaman as its general. Other than the 'No' in the answer what is the difference between what the questions asks and what the answer is?
  5. Forfeiting could cause point shenanigans. Simply better if player A no longer participates?
  6. I think we left Shadespire a long time ago, but i'm enjoying this back and forth about the meaning of the words. I'm not descending into the grammar point, but I the question of whether you can have 'all of nothing' has some philosophical value. The point I made was that an absence of something in one place does not logically mean the something is somewhere else. I think one of the earlier posters said it along the lines of - all of the surviving enemies, of which there are none, are not outside of their territory can be flipped as all of the surviving enemies, of which there are none, are not within their territory. There are no cats outside of China does not mean there are cats inside of China - at best you might be able to infer meaning but as I said before (in another context) it does not logically follow that there are cats in China. I think the crux of the division is this - Suppose someone sets you a challenge: gather me all of unicorns on earth . If you go to them with nothing and say, here you go, here are all the unicorns on earth, have you satisfied the challenge? I would say the challenge is impossible to complete. I suspect you would say that you have satisfied the criteria as you have brought them all of the unicorns on earth (i.e. none). Just to stay on topic - I think an errata is still needed. The designer is a higher authority than the community team (I guess), and I happen to agree with the designer (though more for gameplay than anything), but an errata sets it in stone.
  7. It's all looking good to me. We're still riding the wave and it looks like there is a good use of old and new kits to keep the pace of change coming.
  8. Obviously (if it comes), we'll have to await the FAQ for clarification of the rule writer's intention. But I feel a layer of complexity and strategy is removed with the ''community team'' answer.
  9. Can anyone PM me a photo of the construction guide? Thanks Rob Edit: Each page please - I can see i've left myself open to shenanigans in my original request!
  10. FWIW I've bought the Stormcast from Absolution Black. The transaction was smooth, models arrived today and AB kept me informed throughout. Thanks!
  11. Ah, that does make sense, as I don't think the introductory game pdf envisages use of the cards - so game over when opponent is dead.
  12. Side question: Does the game continue if your opponent if wiped out? I've not seen the full rules and the introductory rules are not clear on this. They appear to suggest player choice to play to three rounds or until warband wiped out
  13. They can be out of play/off the board/dead. The use of the phrase 'all surviving enemy fighters'. A card swap out isn't free is it? It costs an activation?
  14. I wonder if it could be done by last post date so long running posts and current are not locked?
  15. Replying to OP: I suppose that if you play a 3 or 4 player game the differences between the two cards become more apparent.
×
×
  • Create New...