Someone Please Mathhammer for me. Skyfire vs Enlightened on the Charge

[redbeardboss]

On the charge and going first what has a better average damage output vs 4+ armour save.

I know people good at math can determine the avg dmg output and im curious if the rerolls from the skyfires make them better in combat then the enlightened if they go first.

[Shadowheart]

Not positive I've got this correct, but here you go. This is assuming there's so Tzaangor Shaman nearby for the +1 to hit.

Enliughted:

6 spear attacks- 3 Hits, 2 wounds, 2.66 after saves
3 Beaks- 1.5 Hits, 0.5 wounds 0.25 after saves.
6 disks- 3 hits, 2 wounds,  2.66 after saves

5.55 Wounds.

 

Skyfires:
6 bow attacks- 3.33 hits, 1.11 wounds, 0.55 after saves
3 Beaks- 2 Hits, 1.1 wounds, 0.55 after saves
6 Discs- 4.5 hits, 4 wounds, 5.34 after saves

6.44 Wounds

 

[Denneysman]

1. shaman only helps skyfires with shooting.

2. how are skyfires hitting more and wounding more with beaks and disk when it has the same stats if the shaman add +1 to hit for enlightened only??

[AverageBoss]

Deleted.

[redbeardboss]

9 hours ago, Denneysman said:

1. shaman only helps skyfires with shooting.

2. how are skyfires hitting more and wounding more with beaks and disk when it has the same stats if the shaman add +1 to hit for enlightened only??

the skyfires if they go first reroll all hit and wound rolls if they go before any enemy unit within 3 of them. So it looks like the skyfires are actually better in combat if you charge with them and select them to attack first than the enlightened

[Planar]

Hey check druchii.net

They got a great probability calculator for AoS

[redbeardboss]

thanks guys