[AoS 2 - Ossiarch Bonereapers Discussion]

3 hours ago, AngryPanda said:

 I predict that Katakros is going to be far more common in lists though, as he still provides that +1 save and a number of other very useful benefits. 

Katakros is only for Mortis Praetorian though.  And we would lose the -1 rend command if we went with that legion. I honestly don't think Petrifex is going to be nerfed after seeing the FNP changes as they lose a ++ save too.

4 hours ago, ACBelMutie said:

Nagash is still quite resillient even if you have to choose between 5++ and 6++. Protection of Nagash has an issue. If they deals you damage and you don't save it or negate it, you must move the miniature and It's not always good, so you can't cast it all the time on him.

If it's a mortal wound then Nagash loses both the 5++ and 6++ because he has his personal ability that gives him 4++. So you're losing 2 ++ rolls, roughly 20% of his survivability. Protection of Nagash should just be changed to a straight teleport without having to take damage and drop the FNP part of the spell imo. At least gives the spell a reason to be used after the change. 

[Powercreep Illusion - Petrifex]

4 hours ago, JackStreicher said:

It‘s not. You‘d have to divide it into useful categories though and define it.

But it is very subjective. "Fun" for me is crunching numbers and taking the best list. It's playing against other people who bring their best lists. Never been to a tournament, but I still want to play a game without handicaps. And really, that's what playing sub-optimal lists is: handicapping yourself for a challenge or a lack on knowledge (and/or being unwilling to learn). If you want a casual game (what you seem to be calling fun) then play open, narrative, or find someone else who likes casual play. Most people who play the game want to game the game and min/max though.