Thanks for the replies!
Nacnudllah:
I was trying to balance the 3" range on the pikes as this would mean a great amount of attacks coming into any unit.
EMMachine:
I was not! I can change it now.
Maybe for massed ranks I could do +1 to hit for 30+ and +1 to wound for 40+?
So my group of gamers really only play Age of Sigmar but I've always wanted to do historical gaming. So I decided to make some AoS warscrolls for historical units. My first attempt is Macedonians: Phalangites, available from Warlord. Let me know what you think!