Jump to content

EMMachine

Members
  • Posts

    1,649
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by EMMachine

  1. Yes it's the same (Core Book FAQ)
  2. The case of being destroyed is a little different (sadly only with FAQ not with ruletext), but it is handled like this. Here we have the definition, when the last model is slain or flees, and in case of the battleplans the ruling is for "destroyed" units. So their they make a difference between slain and flee. Sadly the First blood Battleplan from the corebook only mentions slain (so I'm not sure if GW had the slain or flee definition at the beginning of the edition yet. (so the question is, how many times the "count as slain" is even used anymore except for the I also quite like the ruling that fleeing models are removed as well because in case of lore, it can mean as well that a hero that is slain, can also be a "Enough, I'm out of here" instead of being dead (something that isn't really posible when a fleeing unit is moving instead of removing models).
  3. So, Sigmarpedia hat soeben mit 2200 Artikeln einen neuen Meilenstein erreicht. -- So, Sigmarpedia has just reached a new milestone with 2200 articles.
  4. looking at Tournament Meta, I think the problem is at some point that some builds are quite conflicting with the actual lore of the faction. I mean we had stuff like multiple Abhorrant Archregent or Frostlords on Stonehorn. The first one is basicly a Emperor of multiple courts and the second is the leader of an Alfrostun. In both cases it is quite unlikely that their would be more than 1 of them in the same army (in case of Stonehorns that problem could even be bypassed because 1 Frostlord and 2 Huskards on Stonehorn are actually plausible to play). It should be more importent that stuff that is reasonable from a lore perspectice should be balanced but stuff that could actually conflict with the lore should not be a result to debuff lorefriendly builds. I think here the problem is that for years if not decades the tournament community is the most vocal and that way new players are lead to a quite unhealthy way to play.
  5. The Vyperic Guard is part of the Daughers of Khaine Battletome. (Page 83) At least the Daughters of Khaine are fully included into the Battletome (and the Allegiance for Zainthar Kai was updated becaue it didn't have a Artefact in Broken Realms Morathi).
  6. Do you have the Generals Handbook 2020? In the legends section of the Point Booklet are points for the units that don't have uptodate Warscrolls anymore. For the warscrolls you either need the AoS App or the old Grand Alliance Books. The Legends lists include either the modelranges of the old world in some cases and in other cases they include the models that weren't printed in the Grand Alliance Books. Thats the reason why you don't find the gunmaster in the compendium after it was printed as part of the Ironweld Arsenal in the Grand Alliance Order Book.
  7. The answer is actually on page one of the Core-Rules. Re-Rolls, last sentence: So re-rolls have priority over other abilites.
  8. Let's see it this way. If they wanted that the unit can only shoot if they are the target, the rule would have been within 1" instead of 3" because you have to be in 1/2" that a charge is successful.
  9. I have the strange feeling AoS is the rare case where people refuse to use the names given to the races. I mean, if you are in the Lord of the Ring lore, you would use "Hobbit" instead of "halfling", "Uruk-hai" instead of "halforc"? in germany the elves are called "Elben" instead of the normally used "Elfen". Or when you look at 40k their were Squats instead of Dwarfs. (but also Eldar and Dark Eldar is used more often than Craftworld Eldari and Drukhari). Duardin, Aelf, Orruks or Troggoth have the same right to be used in AoS as Hobbit and Uruk-hai in Lord of the Rings + we don't know if their could be another Orc or Troll based race in the future, that maybe isn't called an Orruk or a Troggoth.
  10. I don't really know what is going on with Yu-Gi-Oh! at the moment (never really played it actively besides some of the console games), but I guess you mean such cases were someone starts the game and is basicly drawing his entire deck in turn one to get Exodia (at least I have seen a video with something like this.) I think this is the main problem with Sentinels. Their is no reason to kill the Shooting phase for 75% of Shooting units when a simple Warscroll change (no mortal wounds on the shooting profile that is used for indirect shooting / long range) would most likely solve that problem.
  11. Okay, when looking with my Smartphone, I get some as well.
  12. Play narrative play. Their you can use any warscroll you want from all years of aos. I think it's more likely that Dracothion would be the battlefield instead of a model on the battlefield. Behemat had the size of an entire region. And Argentine was as large as the entire hanging valleys (which should have a similar size to Dracothion).
  13. Yes, he can. With the Khorne Keyword he is a valide member of the Khorne faction and can get an Artefact from the Blades of Khorne Battletome when played in a Khorne Allegiance.
  14. The entire phase it called attacking sequence. The attacksequence of 40k would slow down AoS extremly. For example 20 Attacks with fast rolling. AoS: roll to-hit together, roll to-wound together, roll saves together, roll damage, allocate every wound 1 by 1. 40k (if they didn't kill of fast rolling entirely): roll to-hit together, roll to-wound together, allocate 1 attack, roll save for that attack, roll damage go back to 3. And yeah, the attacking system of 40k would cripple Elite units and monsters completely. In case of the ability: Maybe the an Attack doesn't means "a single dice roll" and instead means that it has to be during a shooting or melee attack of that unit. So a Shardspeaker can't heal because of an Arcane Bolt or a Lord of Pain because of the "Share the Pain" rule Can you maybe make long range shooting weaker without killing short range shooting? Throwing Axes, Javelins and all sorts of Pistols (maybe even Flamethrowers) are meant to shoot while the unit is in combat. Takting this away would criple such units completly because they basicly would shoot zero to one time in the entire game. If you want to give shooting units with long range shooting a disadventage give them a minimum range of 4" or maybe 6" and those can't shoot in close combat anymore
  15. Hi @Zeblasky Mortal wounds are allocated after all attacks of the attacking unit have been resolved (the same way normal wounds are allocaed). It is basicly a separate wound pool (after those woulds can only be negated by abilites that ignore mortal wounds). The point is, that the game works this way. If an enemy unit for example has 3 weapontypes and attacks one unit you make the following. Rolling to hit, to wound, save and damage for weapon 1 (putting the damage into a pool) Rolling to hit, to wound, save and damage for weapon 2 (putting the damage into a pool) Rolling to hit, to wound, save and damage for weapon 3 (putting the damage into a pool) Only after you handeled the last weapon, the combined pool of weapons 1-3 will be allocated to the models, and this is also the time when Mortal Wounds are allocated.
  16. Strange, I have never seen such popup apps for mobile games here on that page. (or they get blocked in my case) I thought the only adds are stuff like this:
  17. First it was mentioned with March 2021, but they changed the entry to April. And the same with The End of Enlightenment, that first should have been released in February and was changed to March.
  18. If Cursed city was "right around the corner", I think we would definitly know the release month. We have a cursed city novel that should most likely be released the same time as the box. Now their is the problem. Warhammer Community has a black Library coming soon article where they basicly show the releases of the next two months: https://www.warhammer-community.com/blacklibrarycomingsoon/ The problem is, the Cursed City novel is not listed their. We have stuff for march and april listed. It's most likely that the Lumineth Realm-lords Release and maybe Broken Realms Teclis is in march because we still wait on that book: The other books that should be released and april are those It cursed city should be released in march or april, the book Cursed City novel would be shown in this list as well, so we are either in the last week of April (and the Cursed City novel isn't added yet, or the release is in May. To give a comparrison, Direchasm and Warcry Catacombs were in the months as well as their bookreleases: + We had the Bonesplitterz Warband in the Preview as well, that is a May Release.
  19. Looking at the rules, it's up to 5 plus the general (so basicly every hero that isn't a daemonprince).
  20. The thing is, the book should be mentioned here: https://www.warhammer-community.com/blacklibrarycomingsoon/ At least at the moment the only Books mentioned with AoS are the following: The book should be here if it is released at the same time as the Cursed City Box. Especially after the Books for Direshasm and Warcry Catacombs were in the list before their release.
  21. @FlipRecoil The General doesn't get the "Ravagers Command Trait" the entry in the Warscroll Builder only exists because normally only general can get a command trait, but in a Ravagers army 5 different models can have a command trait, so the entry is for the models that aren't your general.
  22. Well let's see if we get a Snake and a Pig as well after having a Rat and a Wolf 😁 After you only will get the rules for the 9th Character in the book it would be quite weird if it is a new model. In my oppinion it would make more sense if they would say: "Here you have rules for Gotrek, Bugmansson or a Knight Questor". A Model that is already released at least. Maybe an Expension. Is it also possible that Warhammer Quest - Cursed City will still wait until May, because the Novel Release is not mentioned yet on Warhammer Community Coming Soon and their is stuff until April on the page at the moment. https://www.warhammer-community.com/blacklibrarycomingsoon/
  23. Sigmarpedia hat soeben 2100 Artikel erreicht. -- Sigmarpedia reached 2100 articles.
  24. Hi, in the rumours engine this Conversion of Sigvald was shown. Here is the video as well how the model was converted.
  25. I think I have seen a Video on youtube, where this Sigvald conversion was made.
×
×
  • Create New...