I liked this review a lot.
For me negative reviews are always much more useful. If they confirm my worst fears, I can dodge that bullet.
If I did not care about the “flaws”, then they are good news.
In this case, they were expecting a game of named characters. Lot of character development and rich campaigns. Also with character equipment, customizable models and so on
I wanted a fast paced game. With quick and gore Combat. I don’t have time for campaigns, but yes for some evening with 2 hours perfect for a couple of games. Having band customization is better for me that having a list of 3 items with one clearly superior.
In summary, they wanted an old fashion GW game. I only want something new. I could play Mordheim if I wanted